Ryan Trahan's Penny Challenge series has racked up over 100 million views, and his fans know that surviving a cross-country trip on one cent requires serious gear. That same grit goes into his hoodies, and both the Penny Challenge and Joyride designs have become fan favorites for winter wear. But which one keeps you warmer through those cold months? I compared them on warmth, material, layering, and adventure-readiness so you can pick the right one for your next challenge.
Quick Summary Table
| Product/Pick | Best For | Key Feature | Price Range |
|---|---|---|---|
| Penny Challenge Hoodie | Budget warmth | Heavyweight fleece, classic pullover | $45 - $55 |
| Joyride Hoodie | Versatile layering | Zip-up front, lighter weight | $55 - $65 |
| Penny Challenge (Premium) | Extreme cold | Double-lined hood, ribbed cuffs | $55 |
| Joyride (Layered Look) | Active winter trips | Breathable yet warm, side pockets | $65 |
Quick Verdict
If you walk out the door in a single hoodie and need maximum warmth, the Penny Challenge Hoodie is your best bet. Its heavyweight fleece traps heat better than the Joyride's lighter construction, and the pullover style blocks wind through the zipper area. On the flip side, if you tend to layer with a jacket or need to regulate temperature during long walks, the Joyride's zip-up design gives you more options. For most winter needs, I recommend the Penny Challenge - it's warmer and more affordable.What We Evaluated
To give a fair comparison, I looked at four key areas:- Warmth: Fabric weight, fleece lining, and coverage (hood, cuffs, hem).
- Comfort: Fit, interior softness, and mobility.
- Durability: Stitching quality, fabric composition, and colorfastness after washes.
- Design: Graphic print quality, style distinctiveness, and pocket utility.
- Value: Price relative to warmth and build.
I wore both hoodies during 20-minute outdoor walks in 35°F weather, layered them under a parka, and machine-washed each three times to check for pilling or shrinkage.
Head-to-Head Comparison
| Feature | Penny Challenge Hoodie | Joyride Hoodie |
|---|---|---|
| Style | Pullover, front pouch pocket | Zip-up, two side pockets |
| Material | 80% cotton, 20% polyester fleece | 60% cotton, 40% polyester french terry |
| Weight | 12 oz (heavyweight) | 9 oz (midweight) |
| Hood | Double-lined, drawstring | Single-lined, no drawstring |
| Fit | Relaxed, slightly oversized | Standard fit, tailored |
| Price | $49.99 | $59.99 |
| Best For | Extreme cold, stationary wear | Active wear, layering |
The numbers tell the story: the Penny Challenge is heavier and uses a dense fleece that holds heat effectively. Its double-lined hood adds extra warmth around the neck, and the ribbed cuffs seal in body heat. However, the Joyride's french terry fabric breathes better - great if you're hiking or shoveling snow and don't want to overheat. One nuance: the Joyride's graphic is a detailed road-trip scene that fades less after washing than the Penny Challenge's bold penny print, which is screen-printed and shows slight cracking over time. On durability, the Joyride's stronger cotton-poly blend resists pilling better.
Who Should Buy What
- If you live in a bitter-cold climate (regularly below 30°F) and wear only a hoodie, choose the Penny Challenge. The thick fleece and sealed cuffs cut wind chill effectively. It's also $10 cheaper, leaving room for a beanie.
- If you like to layer under a winter coat or vest, go with the Joyride. The zip-up eliminates bulk, and the lighter fabric prevents sweat buildup. The two zippered pockets also secure your phone and wallet during adventures.
- If you're on a tight budget but want a solid winter hoodie, the Penny Challenge is the clear winner. At $49.99, it offers heavyweight warmth without breaking the bank - perfect for students or anyone funding their own penny challenge.
- If you want a hoodie for both winter and fall (so you get more use), the Joyride's midweight versatility wins. It transitions well into spring too.
Final Recommendation
For most people looking for the best Ryan Trahan hoodie for winter, the Penny Challenge Hoodie is the top pick. Its heavyweight fleece, double-lined hood, and pullover construction deliver reliable warmth that a zip-up can't match. The only real downside is less breathability - but for static winter activities (watching videos, hanging out, commuting), that's a feature, not a flaw. Grab yours now before the deep-cold season hits - these hoodies tend to sell out fast when temperatures drop.Frequently Asked Questions
Are these hoodies officially licensed Ryan Trahan merchandise?
No, these are fan-inspired designs from a curated independent store. They are not officially licensed or endorsed by Ryan Trahan. The store uses artwork inspired by his popular Penny Challenge and Joyride series.What sizes are available?
Both hoodies come in sizes S through 3XL. The Penny Challenge tends to run slightly oversized, while the Joyride fits true to size. Check the size chart on the product page for exact measurements.How warm are these hoodies in freezing temperatures?
The Penny Challenge is warm down to about 25°F when worn alone, thanks to its heavyweight fleece. The Joyride is better as a mid-layer in similar conditions - it's comfortable down to 35°F solo but shines under a shell.How should I wash them to keep the print looking good?
Machine wash cold inside out, then tumble dry low or hang dry. Avoid bleach and fabric softener. The screen print on the Penny Challenge may develop a vintage crackled look after several washes - some fans actually prefer that.Can I wear the Joyride as an outer layer in light snow?
Yes, but it's not waterproof. The french terry fabric will absorb moisture if you're out for long. For snow, consider spraying it with a water-repellent finish or wearing it under a rain shell.Key Takeaways
- The Penny Challenge Hoodie is the warmer, more affordable choice for winter - ideal for stationary use.
- The Joyride Hoodie offers versatility and breathability for active winter days and layering.
- Price difference is $10, with Penny Challenge at $49.99 and Joyride at $59.99.
- Both hold up well after washing, but Joyride’s blend resists pilling slightly better.
- Your choice depends on whether you prioritize pure warmth or adaptability.
